Pin it
One rainy Saturday, desperate for those familiar coconut-caramel cookies but months away from scout cookie season, I decided to tackle making them at home. After several batches of trial and error (and more than a few tasty mistakes), these homemade rings of joy have become my kitchen triumph. The buttery shortbread base, topped with toasted coconut swimming in caramel, all draped in dark chocolate - it's pure cookie perfection that takes me right back to my scouting days.
Last Christmas, I brought these to our family gathering. My aunt, who's been hoarding boxes in her freezer for decades, couldn't tell they weren't the originals. Now she calls every time her stash runs low, hoping I'll bake a fresh batch.
Cookie Building Blocks
- Fresh unsweetened coconut: The heart and soul of these cookies
- Good butter: Splurge on the European kind
- Dark chocolate: Go for 60% or darker
- Soft caramels: The fresher, the better
- Real vanilla: Skip the imitation stuff
- All-purpose flour: Creates perfect shortbread texture
- Powdered sugar: Makes cookies melt in your mouth
- Heavy cream: Helps caramel stay soft
- Sea salt: Balances all that sweetness
Pin it
Kitchen Magic Steps
- Cookie Base Creation:
- Start with room-temperature butter, beating it until creamy and dreamy. Mix in powdered sugar until it's all fluffy and light. The vanilla goes in next, followed by flour - but don't overwork it. The dough should just come together, like playing with soft sand at the beach. Chill it well - I learned the hard way that warm dough makes sad, spreading cookies.
- Coconut Dreams:
- Spread your coconut on a baking sheet, watching it like a hawk as it toasts. The kitchen starts smelling like a tropical vacation. Keep stirring until each piece turns golden brown - burned coconut can ruin the whole batch. Trust me, I've been there.
- Caramel Magic:
- Unwrap those caramels (my kids love helping with this part) and melt them slowly with cream. Stir in the toasted coconut until every shred is hugged by caramel. This mixture should be warm enough to spread but not so hot it melts your cookies.
- Final Assembly:
- Top each cooled ring with the coconut-caramel mixture. This is where patience pays off - let everything set before you start playing with chocolate. My first attempt was a melty mess because I rushed this step.
I watched my grandma make cookies every Sunday, and she always said rushing ruins good baking. These cookies taught me she was right - especially when I tried to speed through the chocolate coating and ended up with finger prints everywhere.
Sweet Serving Ideas
These cookies shine brightest when shared with friends. I pack them in brown paper boxes lined with parchment for gifting - much prettier than my first attempt using plastic containers where they all stuck together. For parties, I arrange them on my mom's old glass cake stand, which makes them look extra special. They're perfect with afternoon coffee or, my personal favorite, dunked in cold milk while watching late-night TV.
Making Them Your Own
Some days I play around with different twists. Once I used milk chocolate instead of dark (the kids went crazy for those). Another time I sprinkled some sea salt on top right after dipping - game changer! My sister adds crushed pecans to her coconut mixture. Last Christmas, I made tiny ones for cookie boxes, though that tested my patience with all those little rings.
Keeping The Magic
These keep well in a tin with wax paper between layers - learned that after smooshing a whole batch together. They'll stay fresh about a week at room temperature, if they last that long. Mine usually disappear in days. You can freeze them too, just like I used to do with the scout cookies, but let them thaw in the container to avoid weird chocolate spots.
Pin it
You know what's funny? I started making these because I couldn't wait for cookie season, but now my family prefers the homemade version. Something about making them ourselves - the toasting coconut smell filling the kitchen, the messy fun of dipping in chocolate, even the inevitable cleanup - it's become our thing. Sure, they take some time, but that's part of what makes them special. Like my grandma always said, the best cookies come with a story, and these definitely have stories to tell.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What if I don't have a donut cutter?
- Use two round cutters of different sizes to make the ring shape, or try bottle caps.
- → Can I make these ahead?
- Yes, store in an airtight container at room temperature for up to a week.
- → Why is my dough too crumbly?
- Let it warm slightly if too cold, or add a tiny bit more milk if needed.
- → Can I use milk chocolate?
- Yes, though dark chocolate gives the most authentic flavor.
- → Why toast the coconut?
- Toasting adds flavor and crunch. Watch carefully as it burns quickly.