Save
If you're after a ridiculously tasty sandwich that brings together salty crunch and gooey cheese, you gotta try Dill Pickle Bacon Grilled Cheese. When my cravings hit and I'm looking for old-school comfort but still want something fun, I whip up this grilled cheese packed with crispy bacon and zingy pickle slices tucked in cheddar and Swiss that melt all over the place.
Honestly, the first time I fixed this I needed something classic but different. Now my family begs for it on weekends and nobody can resist how bacon and pickles taste together.
Mouthwatering Ingredients
- Cheddar Cheese: sharp and bold, adds a punch and gets super melty—slice from a block if you can
- Dill Pickles: tangy and snappy, cut up fresh whole ones for max crunch
- Swiss Cheese: smooth and mellow melt, deli slices make it extra creamy
- Unsalted Butter: makes the outside crispy and golden, go with the best stuff you've got
- Slices of Bread: stick to classic white or tangy sourdough, pick one with a good crust and pillowy insides
- Bacon: crunchy and smoky, thick slices give more chew and fab flavor
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Serve and Enjoy:
- Give it a minute off the pan so the cheese settles. Slice it up and eat while it’s steaming for max gooeyness
- Cook Slowly and Flip:
- Let your sandwich sizzle on medium-low. When the bottom's good and golden and cheese starts to melt, use a big spatula to turn it over and brown up the other side. You want a crispy crust and cheesy inside
- Top and Grill:
- Lay the second slice of bread on with buttered side facing out. Use a spatula to lightly press it so the cheese sticks and bread browns evenly
- Build the Sandwich:
- Put one slice of bread butter-side on the skillet. Stack on cheddar, lay down bacon strips, add sliced pickles, then layer Swiss cheese
- Butter the Bread:
- Let your butter soften and use a knife to cover one side of each bread piece right to the edges for that epic crunch
- Prepare the Bacon:
- Cook bacon in a skillet on medium so it’s really crisp and brown. Drain extra fat on paper towels. That crunch totally makes it
Save
What really sets this apart is how the pickles balance the rich cheese and bacon. My kids pile on extra pickles for more zing. This one’s locked in as a Sunday lunch favorite and it always hits the spot for us.
Storage Advice
Best part is biting into one right off the pan, but you can keep extras in a sealed box in the fridge for forty-eight hours. Warm it up in a skillet on low to get that crunch back. Microwave’s a no-go since it’ll make everything soggy.
Swaps You Can Make
Switch bacon for turkey or even plant-based versions if you want to keep things lighter. For a deeper flavor, rye bread is awesome, and swap out Swiss with Havarti if you want extra creaminess. No cheddar? Gouda melts just as nicely.
Save
Serving Up Ideas
Goes great with tomato soup or a fresh salad if you want a full meal. Throw some extra pickles on the plate and grab a handful of crunchy chips. If you’re feeling fancy, put an egg on top for brunch vibes.
Grilled Cheese in American Culture
You’ll find grilled cheese in kitchens all across America, always a comfort staple. It became popular back in the Depression because it was cheap and easy to fill up on. Adding bacon and pickles gives today’s sandwiches a playful upgrade that’s tough to beat.
Recipe FAQs
- → What keeps the bread from getting soggy?
Spread butter or mayo on the outer side of the bread, and cook at a steady medium-low heat. Make sure to drain bacon well to avoid extra moisture.
- → Is it okay to switch out the cheeses?
Of course! Try options like provolone, mozzarella, or Monterey Jack. Feel free to mix to find your favorite combo.
- → What’s the easiest way to cook bacon for this?
Fry in a pan, bake it in the oven, or even microwave it until it's nice and crispy. Use a paper towel to soak up any grease before adding it in.
- → Are there meat-free bacon substitutes I can use?
Definitely! Options like smoky tempeh, coconut bacon, or veggie bacon strips can bring that same bold flavor.
- → How do I make the sandwich crunchier?
Cook at a lower heat for a bit longer to maximize crispiness, or press it in a panini maker for bonus texture.