Caprese Cottage Cheese Toast

Caprese Cottage Cheese Toast is my favorite quick meal for when I want something fresh and filling but do not want to spend forever in the kitchen. The combo of juicy tomatoes, pillowy cottage cheese, and tangy balsamic makes each bite taste like summer on bread.

The first time I made this was for a weekend lunch on a lazy Sunday. We ended up eating both toasts straight from the cutting board and there were no leftovers to worry about.

Ingredients

• Extra virgin olive oil: adds richness and helps burst the tomatoes Look for cold pressed oil for the best grassy flavor
• Cherry tomatoes: sweet and tangy go for firm bright red tomatoes without any wrinkling
• Fresh garlic: gives aromatic depth to the tomato topping Choose heavy firm cloves with unbroken skins
• Sugar: balances the acidity of the tomatoes Just a little makes a difference
• Kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper: wake up all the flavors Always freshly grind your pepper if you can
• Sourdough bread: offers chew and crunch once toasted Pick a sturdy artisan loaf with an assertive tang
• Cottage cheese: delivers creaminess and protein Full fat versions are my go to for extra richness
• Fresh basil: brings fragrance and a peppery finish Use leaves that are bright and vibrant with no dark spots
• Balsamic glaze: adds sweetness and acidity for a caprese effect Try a thick high quality reduction for best flavor
• Hot honey: gives a gentle heat that contrasts all the other flavors Use one with real chili for a slow burn

Step-by-Step Instructions

Prep the Tomatoes:

Warm olive oil in a large skillet over medium heat Add the cherry tomatoes garlic sugar a generous pinch of salt and plenty of black pepper Cook for ten to twelve minutes shaking the skillet occasionally and stirring until the tomatoes burst into a chunky sauce Watch as the tomatoes change color and their juices start bubbling This step makes the topping luscious and full of flavor

Toast and Spread:

Toast two thick slices of sourdough bread until crispy and golden Then generously spread each slice with cottage cheese about half a cup per slice Season lightly with salt and pepper The bread should hold up well to the creamy layer and the cooling step keeps the toast crunchy

Assemble the Toast:

Spoon the warm tomato mixture over the cottage cheese making sure to get some of the juices on each piece Top with an abundant sprinkle of chopped fresh basil The heat from the tomatoes will perfume the basil

Finish with Flair:

Drizzle balsamic glaze in a back and forth motion over the toasts Finish each with a swirl of hot honey for a sweet and spicy kick Serve right away for the best experience

Save

Cottage cheese is hands down my favorite part about this recipe because it makes this toast a complete meal I remember piling extra on my slice and my husband laughing as it dripped everywhere but we agreed it was completely worth it

Storage Tips

This toast is at its best when fresh and warm If you must prep ahead you can make the tomato topping and store it covered in the fridge for up to three days Rewarm it gently then assemble the toasts just before serving The cottage cheese should stay refrigerated until the last minute to keep it fresh and creamy

Ingredient Substitutions

If sourdough is not your favorite try whole grain bread or even a hearty rye You can swap cottage cheese for ricotta if you want something a bit richer For the tomatoes grape tomatoes work as they hold their shape during cooking No balsamic glaze No problem Just reduce regular balsamic vinegar over low heat until thickened

Serving Suggestions

This toast makes a wonderful light lunch on its own Pair it with a green salad or a bowl of soup for a heartier meal Sometimes I halve one for breakfast alongside a poached egg When entertaining slice each toast into smaller pieces for an easy appetizer platter

Save

Caprese Origins and Inspiration

The caprese flavor combination of tomato mozzarella basil and balsamic hails from the island of Capri in Italy Here I like to give it an American twist with cottage cheese and sourdough but the balance of creamy cheese garden herbs and sweet tart tomato stays classic Inspired by the street cafes of Rome and backyard tomatoes from summer

Recipe FAQs

→ What type of bread works best for this toast?

Sourdough is ideal for its sturdy texture and tangy flavor, but any hearty, crusty bread will hold the toppings well.

→ Can I substitute cottage cheese with another cheese?

Ricotta or whipped feta are great alternatives, offering a smooth, creamy base for the vibrant toppings.

→ How do I prevent the toast from becoming soggy?

Toast the bread until it's firm and slightly crispy before layering with cottage cheese and tomatoes to maintain texture.

→ Is it necessary to use hot honey?

Hot honey adds a gentle heat, but regular honey can be used if you prefer a purely sweet finishing touch.

→ What pairs well with this toast for a complete meal?

A light green salad or a simple soup complements this toast nicely for a balanced lunch or dinner option.

→ Can I prepare the tomato topping in advance?

Yes, the tomato mixture may be made ahead and stored refrigerated, then rewarmed gently before assembling the toast.