Save
Picture chewy sourdough bread, golden and crispy on the outside with thick stretches of gooey cheese inside. When I'm seriously craving comfort, nothing beats melty cheese packed between buttery toasted slices like this.
One rainy Saturday, I made this and now my partner always asks for it if they’re feeling down. It’s my special go-to when I want something way better than the usual.
Mouthwatering Ingredients
- Unsalted butter: Lends a rich taste so the cheeses really stand out. Go for good-quality butter to get a crunchy outer layer.
- White cheddar cheese: This gives a gentle tang and creamy texture. Buy it as a block instead of shredded so it melts better.
- Cheddar cheese: Brings sharp, classic flavor. Aged cheddar is best for boldness and smooth melting.
- Gruyere cheese: Famous for its sweet, creamy melt. Choose slices that aren’t dried out and smell right.
- Parmesan cheese: Packs a punch with its nutty sharp taste. Freshly grated from a wedge melts most smoothly.
- Sourdough bread: Handles crisping up without turning soggy, and tastes richer than plain white. Grab a loaf with a thick crust and chewy center.
Super Simple Steps
- Serve and Enjoy
- Pull the sandwich off the pan and let it sit for a minute before slicing. The cheese gets just thick enough for you to enjoy that epic cheese stretch.
- Flip and Finish
- Flip gently with a large spatula. Cook till the other side is golden brown and gooey cheese spills out, which usually needs another two to four minutes. Turn down the heat if your bread browns way before the cheese melts.
- Grill to Golden Perfection
- Warm your skillet up over medium heat. Place the sandwich, buttered side down. Let it sizzle for about three minutes until the bottom’s super crisp and golden.
- Assemble the Sandwich
- Cheddar and white cheddar go down first for a creamy base. Now add Gruyere and Parmesan—stuff them right to the edges so every bite counts.
- Butter the Bread
- Spread butter over the outside of your bread slices. Make sure every spot is covered so the bread comes out crispy instead of dry.
Save
Cheddar steals the show for me. My dad used to stack on extra slices and now I pile them up for my kids too. That first crispy bite? Pure satisfaction.
How to Store Leftovers
Wrap any extras in foil and stash them in the fridge for up to two days. To reheat, set them in a nonstick pan over medium heat and get that crust back to crispy. Skip the microwave unless you like soggy bread.
Swap-Out Ideas
If you’re thinking about mixing things up, swap Gruyere for Swiss or fontina. Don’t like strong cheese? Try mozzarella instead of white cheddar to up the melt factor. If you can’t do dairy, your favorite vegan cheese and plant-based butter work great.
Ways to Serve
Dip strips of your sandwich into tomato soup if you’re feeling classic, or pair with a simple salad for a fresh twist. When I serve this for a crowd, I love slicing it into fingers for easy dunking.
Save
A Little Background
People in the US have loved grilled cheese since the early 1900s because it was so easy for anyone to make at home. Crunchy bread and melted cheese are a winning combo—easy to change up, totally tasty, and never goes out of style.
Recipe FAQs
- → Which cheeses melt best for this?
The mix of cheddar, white cheddar, parmesan, and gruyere gives a tasty blend that melts smoothly and has bold flavor.
- → What’s the best bread for this?
Sourdough is sturdy and tasty, but any fresh, firm bread works just as well.
- → How do you get a good crust?
Spread butter generously on the bread’s outer sides and cook it over medium heat for an even, golden surface.
- → Why does my bread burn before the cheese melts?
Keep the flame on medium-low to cook the bread slowly while giving the cheese plenty of time to ooze perfectly.
- → What are the best sides for this?
Serve it with tomato soup, cucumber pickles, or a crisp green salad for a balanced plate.