Save
Craving pizza but want something crispy and playful? These pizza-stuffed waffles come to the rescue. Every time I whip them up for a chill dinner or a quick lunch, the house smells like bubbling cheese and zesty pepperoni. It instantly gets everyone flocking to the kitchen grinning.
The very first time I tried making these was after school on a whim and now my family begs for them on movie nights more than anything else.
Tasty Ingredients
- Shredded Mozzarella: melts super gooey and stretchy get whole-milk if you can for awesome pull
- Sliced Pepperoni: brings all that classic flavor grab it from the deli or slice yourself for chunkier bites
- Pizza Sauce: brings that real pizza taste go for a thick one so you don’t end up with a soggy mess
- Vanilla Extract: just a splash for cozy flavor pure vanilla’s best if you’ve got it
- Vegetable Oil: good for crispy edges light olive oil works too if you want a bit more taste
- Milk: keeps things soft whole milk really amps up the richness
- Sugar: gives a tiny bit of sweet that makes cheese so much better
- Egg: makes everything stick together and adds depth if you use free-range it pops with flavor
- Salt: skip most but sprinkle a bit so it tastes balanced
- Baking Powder: makes them puff up check yours is fresh or they won’t lift
- All Purpose Flour: builds the chewy waffle—not bleached makes them taste better
Easy Step-by-Step
- Finish it Off and Serve:
- Pop the bare waffle half on top gently press and use a knife to cut into four pieces enjoy them warm and melty
- Melt the Cheese:
- Broil those waffles just until the cheese gets bubbly keep watch so nothing burns
- Stuff with Pizza Goodies:
- Spread sauce on the cut side add a bunch of mozzarella then lay pepperoni right to the edges
- Slice the Waffles:
- Once out of the iron cut your waffles in half across the middle be gentle while they’re soft it helps you fill them easily
- Make the Waffles:
- Pour batter into your hot waffle iron fill each spot but don’t let it spill over close and cook until they’re super golden about five to seven minutes
- Prep the Waffle Iron:
- Lightly brush or spray oil on the waffle iron plates so the waffles get crispy and don’t stick
- Mix Things Together:
- Tip your dry mix into the wet in batches stir until you barely see flour streaks that’s the trick for soft waffles
- Stir Up the Wet Ingredients:
- In a new bowl whisk egg sugar milk oil and vanilla until blended make sure sugar’s all mixed in
- Get the Dry Bits Ready:
- In a big bowl whisk flour baking powder and salt mix well so your waffles rise just right
Save
My favorite thing about playing with this dish was how much mozzarella we could cram inside. The cheesier the better—no one griped about gooey centers. My kiddo even renamed them pizza surprise because every bite feels a little bit new depending on what you stuffed inside.
Storage Advice
Stick any leftovers in a sealed container in the fridge and they’ll be good for two days. To keep them even longer wrap each one and freeze. To warm up put them in the oven or toaster oven at 375 until cheese is gooey again and the waffle sharpens up don’t use the microwave unless you don’t mind some mushiness.
Swaps and Substitutes
Swap in other cheeses like cheddar or provolone for a twist. If you want to make it meatless, try some sautéed peppers or mushrooms instead of pepperoni. You can use whole wheat flour if you want it more hearty just know it’ll be a tad denser. For dairy-free, use plant-based milk and cheese options.
Save
Ideas for Serving
I like to toss these pizza waffles next to a leafy salad or something to dunk like marinara. They’re perfect for game day cut small and passed around. They’re even fun lunchbox surprises cold or at room temp the next day.
Pizza Fun in the US
This version of pizza is pure all-American fun and a total blast for anyone who’s into cozy food or has kids around. Think of them kind of like a waffle and a calzone had a mashup. They’re awesome for parties or sleepovers and always make dinnertime more exciting.
Recipe FAQs
- → How can I keep them from going soggy?
It’s best to enjoy them straight from the waffle iron. Stack them on a wire rack to keep airflow underneath, or place them in a low oven to hold their crispness.
- → Can I customize the fillings?
Of course! Swap out pepperoni with cooked chicken, sautéed mushrooms, or even diced ham. Avoid toppings with high moisture content to prevent sogginess.
- → Is it okay to prepare ahead of time?
You bet! Cook them in advance and store in an airtight box. Pop them in the oven or toaster oven to crisp back up before serving.
- → Can I swap the flour for gluten-free?
Yes, use a one-to-one gluten-free flour replacement. Double-check your baking powder, too, to ensure it’s labeled gluten-free.
- → What dipping sauce works best?
Standard pizza sauce is great, but you can mix it up with garlic butter, marinara, or even ranch dressing for an extra twist.
- → Can I use any waffle maker?
Absolutely! Just don’t overfill it. This way, you’ll avoid leaks and ensure everything cooks evenly without sticking.