Cheesy Beef Pasta Shells

Nothing beats diving into these beef and cream cheese stuffed shells when you're craving something cozy. Imagine all the good parts of lasagna and cheesy baked meals, but way easier to make. You get rich beef filling snuggled in soft pasta, topped with bubbly, melty cheese. They're hard to resist, so they're always a hit when you've got a crowd or just need a comfort meal.

Honestly, I first made these for a weekend hangout and everyone wanted seconds. Now these are the go-to dish for birthdays or when it’s chilly outside and people want a real treat.

Hearty Ingredients

• Shredded mozzarella cheese: goes on top for that epic cheese pull and melts beautifully Freshly shred it if you can for best results
• Spaghetti sauce: brings it all together, whether you grab a jar or simmer your own at home with plenty of herbs
• Grated parmesan cheese: gives a sharp punchy flavor and keeps everything together Best flavor comes from a chunk grated by hand
• Sharp cheddar cheese: adds big cheesy taste Grate it yourself for extra melty-ness
• Cream cheese: makes the filling super creamy and a little tangy Grab full-fat and let it soften first so it mixes smoothly
• Seasoned salt and black pepper: brighten up the beef Go with your favorite blend or add extra if you like things bolder
• Ground beef: hearty and savory For great taste, use lean or freshly ground
• Large shell pasta: big enough to hold plenty of stuffing Choose sturdy shells that won't fall apart after boiling

Simple Step-by-Step

Dive In and Enjoy:

Let everything cool off briefly so scooping is easier. These are best when you serve them warm and the cheese is still gooey.

Finish with Sauce and Cheese:

Pour your spaghetti sauce all over, making sure every shell gets some but isn't swimming. Tightly cover with foil to keep things moist while baking.

Bake It All Together:

Slide the foil-covered dish into a 375-degree oven and bake around 45 minutes so the flavors blend. Uncover, sprinkle on the rest of your cheddar and all the mozzarella and keep baking until the cheese is melty and golden, usually another 10 minutes.

Prep and Fill Your Shells:

Stuff the beef mixture into each shell, either with a spoon or your hands. Lay them in a greased 13x9 baking dish (and use a smaller pan if you have too many). Make sure they're nestled in so they bake up evenly and stay full.

Mix in That Cheese:

Drop the heat down low, add in the cream cheese and mix till it's totally smooth—no lumps! Toss in the parmesan and half the cheddar, stirring so it all melts together. Pull off the heat so nothing overcooks.

Get the Creamy Beef Ready:

Brown the beef in a big pan on medium high, breaking it up till it’s all cooked. Pour off all the extra grease so your filling's creamy, not oily. Toss in the seasoned salt and pepper now for even flavor.

Boil Up Those Shells:

Boil your shell pasta in salted water until it’s just cooked through, but not falling apart. Drain well and lay them out on a tray, so they cool off and don’t stick together. It’ll make stuffing way easier later.

Save

Every time I use cream cheese, it turns the filling extra silky. I remember making this on a snowy night when we had a family board game party—everyone was obsessed with the creamy center!

How to Store Leftovers

Just cover and put leftovers in your fridge; they'll be good for up to three days. To freeze, let them cool off, lay them in a freezer-safe pan, and seal it up tight. Let them thaw overnight in the fridge before warming up in the oven. I usually do half a pan just so there’s always a quick meal ready.

Easy Ingredient Swaps

Go with ground turkey or even toss in some Italian sausage for a little heat, if you want something lighter or with more kick. Gluten-free shells totally work—just don't overcook them. If you want a veggie version, load up mushrooms and spinach instead of beef for that same cozy vibe.

How to Serve It

Honestly, they're a meal all on their own, but a crunchy green salad or roasted broccoli is great to lighten things up. Warm garlic bread is perfect for mopping up any extra sauce. For bigger groups, I set out extra parmesan and let people sprinkle it on themselves.

Save

Where This Dish Comes From

Stuffed shells like these are the ultimate comfort food mash-up from the US, borrowing Italian favorites like manicotti and lasagna. Swapping in cream cheese for ricotta gives it an all-American spin and makes the filling super creamy and crowd friendly. It’s the kind of meal meant for sharing around a big table with family and friends.

Recipe FAQs

→ Is it possible to make this ahead?

Sure! Assemble the shells a day early, cover, and chill. Pop them in the oven when you're ready to eat.

→ What ground beef works best?

Go for lean or 80/20 beef for juicy flavor but less grease. Drain any extra fat after cooking.

→ Can I switch out the cheeses?

Yep! Use ricotta or cottage cheese for creaminess, or swap in any shredded cheese you love.

→ Any tips to avoid breaking shells?

Cook shells until just firm, let them cool for a bit, and handle gently when filling to keep them intact.

→ Is this freezer-friendly?

You bet! Freeze before baking, thaw in the fridge overnight, and add a bit more baking time.