Save
This strawberry pie is pure summer joy in every slice and bursts with real fruit flavor in a tender crust. There is no need for gelatin packets or mysterious fillings—the fresh berries cook down into their own jammy goodness, making this pie stand out on any dessert table.
I made this first for a potluck and watched it disappear before any of the chocolate desserts even got touched. Now it is the recipe my friends request for every birthday or picnic.
Ingredients
- Fresh strawberries: provide a naturally sweet and colorful filling so choose berries that are deep red all the way through and fragrant
- Water: brings everything together to create the syrupy jam-like texture when simmered with the berries
- Sugar or your favorite granulated sweetener: balances the natural tartness of the strawberries and creates the perfect gel set look for berries without white spots or super underripe ones
- Salt: just a pinch enhances sweetness and brightens fruit flavor so do not skip this secret
- Cornstarch or chia seeds: help thicken the filling while keeping it silky smooth or you can opt for chia if you prefer a more rustic and nutritious set
- Pie crust: any nine-inch crust you love works here try homemade buttery pastry a store-bought crust or even a nut flour shell for keto or vegan options
- More strawberries for decoration: make the finished pie look as gorgeous as it tastes so save a few of your prettiest berries for the top
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prepare the Crust:
- Blind bake or set up your favorite nine inch crust and let it fully cool on a rack so the filling stays crisp and does not get soggy
- Slice the Strawberries:
- Rinse the berries under cool water hull and slice them evenly to ensure everything cooks at the same speed and you get juicy pieces in every bite
- Make the Filling:
- Add strawberries water sugar salt and cornstarch or chia seeds into a medium pot stir with a wooden spoon so the powder is dissolved and nothing sticks to the bottom then bring to a gentle boil over medium heat
- Thicken the Mixture:
- As soon as you see fat bubbles reduce the heat to low and cook stirring often for a few minutes until the mixture becomes glossy and thick enough to coat the back of your spoon do not walk away as berry fillings can scorch fast
- Assemble the Pie:
- Immediately spoon the warm strawberry filling into the cooled crust and smooth it evenly all the way to the edge using an offset spatula or the back of a spoon
- Chill and Decorate:
- Refrigerate the assembled pie at least three hours or overnight for easiest slicing then top with extra sliced strawberries in circles or fans just before serving
Save
My favorite part is how bright and happy the strawberries look fanned on top. The first time I made this was with my daughter picking berries at dawn. Now we always save a few perfect strawberries to arrange together on the finished pie.
Storage Tips
Store leftover slices tightly covered in the fridge for up to three days. The crust stays crisp if you keep the pie chilled and not cut too far ahead of time. For picnics I pop the cold pie in a cooler and slice at the table for best fresh-out-of-the-fridge results.
Ingredient Substitutions
Swap the sugar for coconut sugar or a monk fruit sweetener to lower the carbs and keep the filling plenty sweet. Chia seeds work especially well for a more fiber-filled pie though the texture will be slightly different. If using frozen strawberries thaw and drain well before cooking and know the filling may need a few more minutes to thicken up.
Serving Suggestions
Serve generous wedges with clouds of whipped cream or coconut whip for a dairy free twist. Sometimes I spoon vanilla Greek yogurt alongside for a not-too-sweet brunch offering. For extra flair I drizzle with melted dark chocolate or sprinkle on toasted almond slivers.
Save
Cultural and Historical Context
Classic strawberry pie recipes became wildly popular in early American diners thanks to plentiful summer berry harvests and easy pie crusts from scratch. Some Southern cooks thicken with flour or even gelatin but nothing beats the pure taste of strawberries gelled with just sugar and a bit of starch.
Recipe FAQs
- → How can I keep the strawberry filling from becoming runny?
Thickening agents like cornstarch or chia seeds help the filling set. Stir the mixture constantly as it cooks and allow time to chill fully before slicing.
- → Can I use frozen strawberries?
Frozen strawberries may be used, but thaw and drain them first to avoid excess moisture in the filling.
- → What crust options work best?
Traditional, graham cracker, or specialty crusts such as keto or vegan provide great foundations for the strawberry filling.
- → How should leftovers be stored?
Cover and refrigerate leftover slices to maintain freshness and texture for several days.
- → Can I adjust sweetness levels?
Yes, you can use less sugar or choose a preferred sweetener to suit your taste without impacting consistency.