Grilled Cheese Pizza

Cheesy goodness and pizza flavors get tucked inside crispy toasted bread This mashup is total comfort food and it's my go-to when I want something fun and cozy It's a real crowd-pleaser and always sets off big grins at dinner

This all started when my niece asked for both grilled cheese and pizza at once Now it's our family's favorite movie-night meal Nobody ever minds having extras for the next day

Tasty Ingredients

• Extra virgin olive oil: Makes the sandwich toast up better and adds little bursts of flavor Pick a fresh bottle for best results
• Salted sweet cream butter: Helps your sandwich turn golden and gives a rich, smooth taste Melting it first makes sure it spreads on bread easily
• Soft Italian sandwich bread: Stays fluffy and copes with all the fillings Look for fresh bread from the bakery section
• Dried Italian seasoning: Throws in classic pizza flavors with garlicky herbs Make sure it's still fragrant for the best taste
• Onion powder: Sneaks in a gentle savoriness Skip clumpy powders so everything mixes smoothly
• Pepperoni: Packs a big salty punch Go for regular slices, not minis, for better snacking
• Smoked provolone cheese: Adds rich, smoky notes that play nicely with mozzarella Plus, it melts to a creamy finish
• Freshly grated mozzarella cheese: Since it has less starch, it melts beautifully and gives you that epic cheese pull Fresh is best here
• Pizza sauce: Gives a pop of tang and keeps the sandwich juicy Use a thick, herby tomato sauce for sturdy, tasty sandwiches

Easy Instructions

Finish It Up:

Move the sandwiches off the skillet and onto a board Give them a minute to let the cheese settle Slice 'em in half and dig in while they're hot

Crisp and Melt:

Fry both sides for three or four minutes until golden and the cheese turns melty Watch your heat Don't let the bread burn and press down with a spatula for extra crunch Carefully flip with a wide spatula

Sauce and Cheese Time:

Spoon two tablespoons pizza sauce on each unbuttered side Add a slice of provolone, then a quarter cup of mozzarella Build your cheesy layers one by one

Layer More Goodies:

Drop twelve slices of pepperoni onto that mozzarella Sprinkle more mozzarella by the handful Top everything with another slice of provolone Cheese goes on every layer to make things extra gooey

Top and Butter:

Lay your second bread slice on each sandwich with the buttered side up Press everything together Brush the tops with more of your butter mix so they get that rich finish

Butter Prep:

Stir up the melted butter, olive oil, Italian seasoning, and onion powder in a bowl Mix well so every bite is packed with flavor

Start It Right:

Spoon the seasoned butter onto one side of every bread slice Completely cover each piece Focus on what will be the outside when you grill

Get Grilling:

Set a nonstick pan on the stove, medium heat Lay two slices, buttered side down, once the pan's hot You should hear a faint sizzle right away

Save

Honestly, smoked provolone is what takes this sandwich to another level I really love the subtle tang and the hint of smoky flavor My niece goes wild for that stretchy cheese moment when you pull the halves apart and honestly, me too

Keeping It Fresh

If you've got leftovers, wrap them in foil once cooled and pop in the fridge up to two days Warm up in a skillet on medium-low heat so the bread stays crisp Avoid the microwave unless you want soggy sandwiches Stove is best every time

Swaps & Changes

If you don't eat pepperoni, swap in salami, ham, or your favorite roasted veggies Out of provolone Just do all mozzarella or throw in some cheddar for zing Want to lighten things up Use whole wheat bread For a meatless option, double the cheese and add bell peppers or olives instead of meat

Serving Ideas

Cut each sandwich into quarters and you've got the perfect party snack or game night finger food I like to serve them with some fresh salad and a tangy vinaigrette Dip them in marinara or ranch on the side Everyone's happy that way

Save

Cultural Spin

This pizza grilled cheese mixes two American icons in one gooey bite It's quick to cook but gets its flavors from those Italian American pizza shop classics We get lots of laughs picking toppings and making it our own as a family

Recipe FAQs

→ How can I make cheese melt better?

Let the cheese sit at room temperature for about 15 minutes before using. This helps it get evenly gooey while cooking.

→ What’s the best bread choice?

Thick Italian-style slices are sturdy and crisp, holding up well to all the cheese and toppings.

→ Can I grill these in a press?

Definitely! A panini press ensures an evenly crispy crust and helps melt the cheese perfectly.

→ What are good cheese substitutes?

Try cheddar for sharpness or Monterey Jack for a mild twist, though mozzarella and provolone are classic.

→ How do I avoid burning it?

Keep the heat to medium and flip to check progress often. Adjust as needed for even browning.

→ What toppings can I add?

Feel free to throw on mushrooms, peppers, or olives for that extra pizza flair.