Save
If you're after a meal that's both fun and super simple to toss together, this pepperoni pizza tater tot casserole totally fits the bill. You just pile everything in one pan and bake—no fuss, just a yummy dish that brings together all those pizza flavors and crispy potatoes everyone can't get enough of. This is the one I turn to when I want happy faces at dinner and barely any dishes left behind.
The first time I made this my kids couldn't even wait for dinner—they kept stealing bites as I tried to set it out Now every time they see pizza night on the calendar, they ask for this version first
Amazing Ingredients
- Grated parmesan cheese: Adds salty, nutty flavor right on top Totally optional but makes a real difference Freshly grated melts better but pre-grated is good too
- Pepperoni: Delivers those classic pizza vibes Go with mini or standard pepperoni, whatever you like Best ones have a bit of orangey oil for flavor
- Shredded mozzarella cheese: Melts into gooey goodness Makes that stretchy cheese pull everyone loves Go fresh or grab the bagged stuff either works
- Pasta sauce: Brings tangy tomato kick Pick a thick sauce so things don’t get soggy No shame in using store-bought
- Frozen tater tots: Get that crisp golden crust and fluffy centers Pick a reliable brand so the texture’s right
Simple Step-by-Step
- Let it Cool Off and Dish Up:
- Once the dish comes out, leave it for about five minutes so everything settles You’ll get cleaner slices and less mess Add a sprinkle of parsley, ranch drizzle, or extra herbs if you like
- Into the Oven:
- Stick in the middle of a 400 degree oven and cover it up with foil Bake for twenty minutes, then uncover and let it keep going for fifteen The outside should get that lovely sizzle and a good golden color before you take it out
- Build More Layers:
- Repeat the layers with the rest of the tots, sauce, mozzarella, and finish with pepperoni Put all the leftover cheese plus parmesan right on top, so it bakes up a golden crust
- Get Started With Layers:
- Lay tater tots from the freezer right into your pan (half the bag) Space them out so everyone gets bites with crispy potatoes Spoon over half the leftover sauce, then toss on half the mozzarella Lay down another third of your pepperoni pieces
- Layer First:
- Coat the bottom of your dish with some pasta sauce so nothing sticks and it starts the flavor Drop a handful of pepperoni for extra taste
- Prep the Pan:
- Slick your baking dish with oil or spray to stop sticking Helps everything come out easy
Save
I can’t get enough of that pepperoni Coming out of the oven, the edges turn extra crisp and curly over that melty cheese No one waits for me to serve—last time my littlest just grabbed a bite before it had even cooled 'cause it smelled so good
Handy Storage Advice
Pop extras in the fridge with a tight cover and keep for three days Max flavor and crispy texture if you reheat in the oven or an air fryer Microwave will do, but makes the tots a bit soft
Ingredient Swaps
If you want a change, try using cooked sausage instead of pepperoni Or skip the meat and layer in mushrooms, spinach, or olives For dairy-free, use your go-to cheese substitute and just pile it on thick so it melts all the way Pizza sauce works for a slightly sweet twist if you prefer
Easy Ways to Serve
Put this out as the star of dinner with some broccoli or salad on the side If you love dipping, a side of ranch or warm marinara is always a win Tiny bit of red pepper flakes adds fun heat for adventurous eaters
Save
Fun Cultural Background
This cozy casserole has roots in American Midwest comfort food The pizza spin makes it a guaranteed crowd-pleaser for everyone Blends hearty tradition and favorite pizza flavors for the best of both worlds
Recipe FAQs
- → Can I change up the toppings?
Of course! Toss in stuff like sausage, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers, or olives to mix things up.
- → What kind of sauce should I grab?
Stick to a standard tomato pasta sauce—it's simple, widely available, and brings that classic pizza vibe.
- → Do I need to thaw the tots first?
Nope, they're good to go straight from the freezer. They'll crisp up perfectly in the oven.
- → How should I store the leftovers?
Pop leftovers into an airtight container and refrigerate for up to 3 days. Reheating in the oven keeps them crispy.
- → Can I make it ahead of time?
Totally! Put it together, cover, and stash in the fridge. Bake it fresh when you're ready to serve.