Save
This icing for sugar cookies is my favorite for every celebration and birthday baking. It only uses four easy-to-find ingredients and comes out shiny, creamy, and ideal for cookie decorating in no time. The best thing is that it firms up enough for stacking while keeping a soft texture when you take a bite.
I first used this icing for a bake sale for my daughter and was amazed at how fast it dried compared to other glazes. Now, every family event features a platter of beautifully decorated cookies thanks to this fail-proof icing.
Ingredients
- Powdered sugar: makes it super smooth and mixes in easily, always grab a fresh bag without lumps
- Light corn syrup: gives it a nice shine and helps it set with just the right sweetness, use clear syrup for the brightest colors
- Milk: helps get the right texture, whole milk adds richness while skim works in a pinch
- Vanilla extract: adds that classic bakery scent; pure extract gives the best flavor, though almond extract is a tasty swap
- Food coloring (optional): adds a fun pop of color to the icing, gel colors can produce bright shades with just a drop or two
Instructions
- Combine the Base:
- In a medium bowl, mix the powdered sugar, milk, vanilla extract, and light corn syrup. Whisk until it’s totally smooth and looks glossy. The icing should be thick enough to hold a ribbon when the whisk is lifted.
- Modify Consistency:
- If you'd like a shinier and thinner icing for flooding cookies, add milk in half-teaspoon increments, beating well after each addition. Keep going until it flows off a spoon slowly but doesn’t pool rapidly.
- Color the Icing:
- Split the icing into smaller bowls. Add food coloring one drop at a time, mixing well until you get the shades you want. Always start with a small amount since the colors get richer as they sit.
- Decorate the Cookies:
- Grab a small knife, spoon, piping bag, or squeeze bottle to spread or pipe the icing on the cooled cookies. Start with the edges first for clean lines, then fill in the centers with some extra icing.
- Allow to Dry Fully:
- Put the decorated cookies on parchment paper and let them air dry for a few hours or until they’re set and no longer sticky to the touch. Once dry, feel free to add sprinkles or edible glitter for extra flair.
I always use clear corn syrup for the best shine in my icing, even after it dries. One of my favorite memories is our yearly snow day tradition when my kids and I sit around decorating loads of cookies in every color imaginable.
Storing Tips
Keep any leftover icing in an airtight container at room temp for up to three days. If it thickens too much, mix in a bit of milk before using. After icing, let the cookies dry completely before stacking or packaging them to keep the decorations from smudging.
Ingredient Swaps
If corn syrup isn’t on hand, you can use honey instead, but it might make the icing darker and alter the flavor a bit. Almond extract can replace vanilla for a nice scent, and plant-based milks will work just as well for a dairy-free version. For coloring, natural powders like beet or spirulina can be a fun homemade choice.
Serving Ideas
This icing isn’t just for sugar cookies. Try it on different treats like shortbread, gingerbread, graham crackers, or even drizzled on cinnamon rolls. For gatherings, set out bowls of colored icing and sprinkles for a fun activity for the kids.
Cultural Insights
Traditional royal icing usually uses egg whites, but this corn syrup method became popular in home kitchens because it’s easy and safe. Modern bakers appreciate how quickly it dries and how reliably it creates a stunning cookie display.
Seasonal Variations
Add peppermint extract in winter or citrus for a spring touch. Use pastel colors for Easter or bright tones for birthday parties. For festive cookies, finish with sparkling sanding sugar for extra fun.
This quick and easy icing comes together fast and works for any cookie shape or occasion. It hardens well, so cookies can be safely packed in lunchboxes or gift tins.
Common Recipe Questions
- → How can I adjust the icing's consistency?
If you want thinner icing to flood cookies, add more milk, a half teaspoon at a time. Use less for piping outlines.
- → Can I use a flavor besides vanilla?
Sure, almond extract works well if you want a different taste in your icing.
- → How do I add color to the icing?
After mixing everything else in, stir in small amounts of food coloring for bright colors.
- → How long does the icing take to harden?
The icing starts to thicken in about 20–30 minutes, and it will fully harden in a couple of hours, depending on how thick it is.
- → What's the best method to apply this icing?
You can use a spoon, a small knife, a piping bag, or a squeeze bottle to get smooth, even coverage on cookies.