Save
Pepperoni Pizza Quesadillas are always my favorite fix when hunger strikes and I want something good in no time. All those pizza flavors get packed inside a crispy tortilla. These totally satisfy at noon or way past dinner. They come together in just a few minutes. Everyone loves dunking those cheesy wedges in hot marinara.
This all started when I tried to make dinner fast and my kids wanted delivery. Now, it's our usual trick—mixing up the cheeses, trying new dips, and letting everyone help press quesadillas on the pan.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Pizza or marinara sauce: the ultimate dunk, use your go-to jar or homemade if you have it
- Olive oil or butter: gives that golden crunch, butter makes it rich
- Garlic powder: gives toasty warmth, check that your jar smells fresh
- Dried oregano: that classic pizza smell, pick a nice one
- Sliced pepperoni: tons of flavor, mini pepperoni works best for every bite
- Shredded cheddar cheese: sharp flavor and color, sharp cheddar is our pick
- Shredded mozzarella cheese: makes the cheese stretch and pull, freshly grated always melts better
- Medium flour tortillas: the holder for it all, grab soft and fresh ones so they crisp but won’t break
Easy Step-by-Step
- Serve with Sauce
- Scoop out bowls of your chosen pizza or marinara sauce for friends or family to dunk their hot wedges.
- Finish and Slice
- Work through all the leftover tortillas and things you stuffed them with. Let each one chill for a minute so the filling doesn’t ooze everywhere, then divide into slices for grabbing and dipping.
- Crisp the Quesadilla
- Pop the folded tortilla onto your warmed-up skillet. Let one side go for a few minutes till nice and crunchy, push down with a spatula, flip, and cook the other side so it’s all golden with melted cheese inside.
- Assemble Each Quesadilla
- On a board, set a tortilla flat then sprinkle on mozzarella and maybe cheddar over one half. Add pepperoni on top, shower with oregano and garlic powder, and then fold to make a half-moon filled with goodness.
- Heat the Skillet
- Grab a big pan, get it hot with a quick slick of oil or butter, coating the surface so everything browns up right.
Save
When my kids bite into gooey stacks and grin with marinara dripping, I’m really glad for easy meals like this. Sharp cheddar is number one for us—it kicks up the flavor big time every bite.
Saving Leftovers
Just wrap extra wedges in foil or pop them in a sealed container in the fridge, they’ll stay good for about three days. Re-warm in a skillet or toaster oven to bring the crunch back. A microwave gets it hot in a hurry but makes it softer.
Tasty Switch-Ups
Try tossing in other favorite toppings like olives, mushrooms, or peppers for a new spin. Turkey pepperoni is great if you want a lighter bite. You can also use wheat or gluten-free tortillas if you like.
Fun Ways to Serve
Pair these with a quick green salad for a laid-back dinner or put out as snacks before the main meal. For something different, set up bowls of sauces like pesto, ranch, or BBQ and let folks pick how they dip.
Save
How This Tasty Mashup Happened
This happened because my crew wanted pizza and a snack to grab at the same time. Quesadillas are a classic from Mexican food but are perfect for mixing up. The pepperoni pizza taste just works, especially when we’re hanging out at home.
Recipe FAQs
- → How can I get my quesadilla extra-crispy?
Get your skillet nice and warm first, and add a little olive oil or butter. Press lightly with a spatula for an even golden crunch.
- → Can I swap mozzarella for other cheeses?
Totally! Cheddar, provolone, or Monterey Jack are all great choices. Mixing a few kinds makes the flavors even better.
- → What's the easiest way to reheat leftovers?
Warm them in a skillet on medium heat so they crisp up again. Skip the microwave—it'll leave them a bit soggy.
- → What can I use instead of pepperoni?
You can substitute with cooked sausage, veggies, or even mushrooms. Just pick what you enjoy or works for your diet.
- → Do I have to use marinara sauce?
Not at all! Marinara’s classic, but ranch or a garlic aioli dip works great too.
- → Can I make these ahead of time?
They’re best straight from the pan, but you can put them together earlier, refrigerate, and cook when ready to eat.