
Nothing hits the spot quite like making a sausage egg and cheese McMuffin at home. It’s that classic breakfast you always crave, but this time even better because you made it yourself. You get a gooey slice of cheese, juicy breakfast sausage, and a just-right cooked egg, all wrapped up between a warm, toasty muffin. Skip the line—these come together fast right in your kitchen.
I whipped up these copycat McMuffins the first time when I was wanting one on a Sunday and couldn’t find an open spot nearby. My family now insists homemade is way tastier, so these are part of our Saturday morning ritual.
Tasty Ingredients
- Eggs: Grab the biggest freshest ones you can. They’ll turn out fluffier and keep their bright yellow color. Organic or from a local spot is even better.
- Cheese slices: American or cheddar both give you that old-school melty vibe. Any cheese that melts well will work and make the sausage and egg extra comforting.
- Butter or oil: Use a dab, just enough so things slide around and get golden.
- Sausage patties: This is what makes breakfast feel special. Mix up your own with your kind of seasonings or pick out a solid store-bought patty.
- Salt and pepper: Keep it simple and add a pinch as you go for exactly the flavor you want.
- English muffins: Pick the freshest muffins, preferably the ones with a bit of flour dust on top, and toast them for crunch.
Simple How-To Steps
- Enjoy or Save:
- Dive in right away for gooey goodness or wrap up to warm later if you’re headed out the door.
- Build Your Sandwich:
- Lay down a slice of cheese on the toasted bottom half, pile on a hot sausage patty, then your egg. Finish it all up with the top muffin layer. The heat does the rest, making the cheese all soft and melty over everything.
- Cook the Eggs:
- Grease up a ring mold or even use a mason jar lid in your pan. Crack an egg inside. Let it cook on its own till the white isn’t wobbly and the yolk is how you like—takes about two or three minutes. Add a touch of water around the molds and toss a lid on if you want the tops cooked through.
- Brown the Sausage:
- Set your sausage patties down in the hot skillet. Sear each side for three or four minutes. Flip them once so they brown up outside. Move them off to a plate when they’re cooked through.
- Crisp Up the Muffins:
- Butter up the cut side of your muffins and press them into a medium-hot pan till they’re browned and toasty. This step keeps the middle from getting soggy and gives you a great base to build the rest.

I’ll always pick the eggs as my favorite part. When the eggs pop into shape inside those rings, I remember my kids huddled at the stove on a chilly day, watching them set and asking for one more bite.
Best Ways to Store
If you end up with extra sandwiches, let them cool off, then wrap tight in foil or plastic and pop in the fridge. You can microwave or warm them in the oven the next day. They’ll stay tasty for two or three days with no problem.
Swap-Out Ideas
If you want to lighten things up, reach for turkey or chicken sausage instead. Whole wheat English muffins boost fiber. You can totally toss in a different cheese too—Swiss or pepper jack are both awesome picks.
Serving Up Ideas
Add fruit or some crispy hashbrowns for a full breakfast. A splash of ketchup or hot sauce really takes it up a notch and gets you that real diner flavor.

The Story Behind It
Sausage egg and cheese McMuffins first landed at McDonald’s in the ‘70s because folks wanted breakfast on the go. It’s no surprise they blew up. Making them yourself at home lets you customize every bite.
Recipe FAQs
- → What's the trick to keeping eggs round?
Use a metal ring or the lid of a mason jar in your pan. That keeps the eggs nicely contained and round, perfect for fitting on the muffins.
- → Can I switch out the cheese type?
Of course! Cheddar, Swiss, or even American cheese all work great. Each gives its own unique flavor and melting goodness.
- → How do I stop sausage patties from cooking unevenly?
Press the patties into a flat shape before cooking so they cook through more evenly. Medium heat is best to avoid overcooking.
- → Can I make these muffins ahead of time?
Definitely! Assemble the sandwiches, wrap them in foil or parchment, and chill. Heat them up later for a quick grab-and-go breakfast.
- → How do I melt the cheese perfectly?
Put the cheese right on the toasted muffin base, add the hot sausage and egg, and top it off with the other half. The heat does the melting for you.