Save
These homemade easy pop tarts are my favorite way to recreate that classic breakfast treat at home. They come together with only a handful of ingredients and they always taste even better than what you find in the store. You can customize the filling to whatever you are craving and top them with as many sprinkles as you like.
I remember making these for my kids on a rainy weekend. They loved choosing their own jam for the filling and decorating the tops. It became our new tradition for cozy mornings.
Ingredients
- Pre-made pie crusts: This shortcut creates the perfect flaky layering and saves so much time Look for cold dough with no cracks or dryness
- Fruit jelly: Any flavor you love works Strawberry and raspberry are always a hit Choose a high fruit content for real fruity flavor
- Egg: The secret to a shiny golden top Fresh eggs whisk up best for a beautiful finish
- Powdered sugar: Essential for a melt in your mouth icing Sift before using to avoid lumps
- Milk: Used to loosen the icing Whole milk will give a richer glaze but any kind will work
- Sprinkles: Not just decoration They give a playful pop of color that kids love Use bright and fresh ones for best effect
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prep Your Baking Sheet:
- Line a large baking sheet with parchment paper to prevent sticking and make cleanup even easier
- Cut the Dough:
- Roll out the pie crusts on a nonstick surface and use a pizza cutter to slice rectangles about three inches by five inches Try to keep them uniform for even baking
- Add the Filling:
- Spoon a generous amount of fruit jelly onto half the dough rectangles Spread the jelly to about half an inch from the edge so it does not leak out
- Seal the Tarts:
- Place the other dough rectangles on top Gently press the edges together and use a fork to crimp all the way around Create a tight seal so the filling stays in place
- Brush and Bake:
- Beat the egg well and brush it over the tops of the pop tarts This helps them bake to a beautiful golden color Bake in a preheated oven at 425 degrees F for about seven minutes until the edges are just turning golden
- Cool and Ice:
- Let the pop tarts cool completely before icing or the glaze will run off Mix powdered sugar with a splash of milk adjusting to get your favorite drizzling consistency Drizzle over each pastry and finish with sprinkles
Save
My favorite part is the homemade fruit filling It reminds me of my grandmother who always let us pick out our favorite jam for special breakfasts The way the warm filling bubbles inside the dough is pure comfort
Storage Tips
Keep cooled pop tarts in an airtight container at room temperature for two days For longer freshness refrigerate and rewarm in the toaster for a couple minutes They also freeze beautifully Just wrap individually and store for up to a month
Ingredient Substitutions
You can swap out pie crust for homemade pastry if you want a slightly more buttery flavor Any kind of fruit preserve works and you can even use chocolate or nut spread instead For the icing plant milk or a simple lemon glaze are great options
Serving Suggestions
These pop tarts are a perfect breakfast alongside a cup of coffee or tea They also make a fun dessert topped with a scoop of ice cream For brunch parties set up a decorating station so everyone can add their own sprinkles
Save
Cultural Context
Homemade pop tarts are inspired by the classic toaster pastries that have been part of American breakfast tables since the 1960s Making them at home with real ingredients keeps that spirit of fun but brings so much more flavor and freshness
Recipe FAQs
- → Can I use homemade pastry instead of pre-made pie crust?
Yes, homemade pastry can be substituted for store-bought crust. Just roll it out thinly and use as directed for a similar flaky texture.
- → What types of fruit jelly work best?
Any smooth fruit jelly or jam works well, such as strawberry, raspberry, or blueberry. Avoid those with large fruit pieces for even spreading.
- → How do I store leftover pop tarts?
Store cooled pop tarts in an airtight container at room temperature for up to two days, or refrigerate for up to a week.
- → Can I freeze baked pop tarts?
Yes, baked and fully cooled pop tarts can be frozen in a freezer bag for up to two months. Toast to reheat before eating.
- → Is it necessary to brush with egg before baking?
Brushing with egg wash helps create a shiny, golden finish, but you can skip it if desired. The pastry might be paler without it.
- → Can I use another glaze instead of the one suggested?
Cream cheese frosting, chocolate drizzle, or even a plain powdered sugar glaze all make delicious alternatives for topping.